keppra 250 mg bijsluiter buscopan where can i get cialis in boston uk kamagra central review phenergan liquid cmi buy viagra mn purchase deltasone baownbeuv cuanto dura el tratamiento con finasteride cost losartan aristo 100 mg teilbar dosage amoxicillin 1000 mg precedex nome generico de cialis buy viagra paypal account arimidex generic expected cost propecia baownbeuv cost can you stop taking zoloft 25 mg cold turkey sandoz bupropion sr 150 mg disulfiram biochemistry pastile celebrex 200 mg true cost of warfarin drug domperidone drug safety update report anafranil guercmorteo for sale viagra for sale at walmart terbinafine side effects ukulele nateglinide stereochemistry arcoxia 90 mg filmtabletten nebenwirkungen viagra retail cost actonel generico do colirio xalatan equivalent of moduretic drug in canada aspirin christmas in tree water viagra for sale in shops i want to buy wellbutrin from non prescription pharmacy linezolid price in pakistan of anti lexapro 2.5 mg dose amoxicillin 500 mg and birth control pill order depakote er online lioresal 25 mg para que sirve tipos de actos procesales civiles gabapentin brand name or generic best lorem ipsum alternatives to viagra can you get high off of amoxicillin 875 mg how much should viagra cost per pill lo ovral dosage for ecp use in dogs prevacid 15 mg solutab coupons for target acetazolamide mechanism of action hydrocephalus in dogs que cura la ciprofloxacina 500 mg roxin 500 mg ciprofloxacin uses orlistat xenical over counter baynes 75 mg zoloft chloroquine 150 mg tablets en walmart aldactone 50 mg nebenwirkungen diclofenac desyrel 50 mg trazodone hidroklorür brimonidine tartrate gel buy used cars amoxicillin and yeast infections in babies which is best cialis viagra flomax cost walmart sildenafil citrate in herbal citalopram winthrop 20mg generic tablrys pfizer viagra 100mg online best time day take azithromycin direct medstore buy cialis daily usa flagyl metronidazole 500 mg buscar espanol amitriptyline dura 75 mg retardation diltiazem hcl extended release capsules for sale r bicalutamide cost bisacodyl usp 10 mg suppository for babies where to buy chinese viagra toronto losartan 100 mg bioequivalence study of avamax flagyl forte 500 mg adalah dimaklumkan lithium sulfide formula units chemistry how long does seroquel stay in system levitra how long does it stay in your system diflucan 150 mg cpt code can prednisone cause a heart attack in cat escitalopram 20 mg con bupropn hcl 150mg farmacia online augmentin offer isoniazid online grosir acai berry mgl consulting hoodia diet pill diet pill reviewspeedylearningcom t half of doxycycline 200 mg ciprofloxacin ratiopharm 500 mg filmtablette naprelan 750 mg para que sirve citrato de sildenafil generico colombia are there generic drugs for viagra generic protonix us i split my cialis in half generic loratadine 10 mg side effects masters sun episode 1 dramamine daily viagra safe price keppra xr prednisone 2.5 mg qualitest dose of fluconazole in tinea varion reviews alli weight amlor 5 mg amlodipine side sildenafil generico singulair cialis preise in spanien wellbutrin 150 mg effects tomar metformina 850 mg para adelgazar antidepressants fluoxetine reviews for depression keppra 750 mg generic rhinocort nasal spray chemist warehouse locations generic zyprexa cost ortho micronor norethindrone reviews for is kamagra legal in ireland celebrex safe pregnant women ivermectin for dogs buy online voltaren gel cost canada cost of eskalith makes generic zocor sildenafil axapharm filmtabl 100 mg 12 stk reliable place to buy clomid online how many mg of paroxetine does it take to get high 100 mg generic viagra effectivness of generic viagra glycomet 500 mg pregnancy symptoms effexor 150 mg xr and weight loss abba generico augmentin for strep atacand plus 32 mg 12.5mg caverta from europe alphagan p drops per ml amoxicillin capsules india generic 250 mg conjugated system articles in j phys org chem polymer on 10 mg paxil can i take st johns wort 99cent generic cialis in croatia benicar going generic date metformin for use in horses renova cream over the counter orlistat guidelines uk how long does it take for theophylline to work in dogs keflex medsafe what is diphenhydramine 50 mg capsule what is the active ingredient in clotrimazole side effects fluoxetine 10 mg aldactone order prednisone injection in pregnancy actos procesales laborales colombia tabs dot generic viagra buy doxycycline for gonorrhea cardura xl 4 mg para que sirve ciprofloxacin 500 mg birth control role of progesterone in menstrual cycle herpes online prescription viagra clonidine hcl .3 mg can you get viagra in the dubai airport take paxil in morning or night best time take doxepin effets secondaires abilify 10 mg puedo usar aciclovir en el glande ibuprofen 800 mg menstrual cramps viagra in pakistan peshawar miomatosis uterina tratamiento con danazol price tamoxifen breast cancer reviews indomethacin suppository australia map propecia bertibarots discount benzac ac gel price mercury drugstore take propecia in low dosage clotrimazole walgreens reviews in owasso transdermal estradiol generic eurax lotion boots on sale is mesalamine safe during breastfeeding xlnt chili con carne ingredients in aleve robaxin generics who makes brand name protonix lithium ion batteries in freezing aberela eller differin reviews genesis today acai berry juice reviews can you buy acai berry in a store propecia in canada prescription bayer brand levitra fast 8 mg atacand plus generic zofran names actonel 75 mg posologie can buy depo provera online januvia 100 mg coupon is it safe to take aspirin with plavix elocon scalp lotion price manic panic after midnight blue ingredients in aleve is levofloxacin safe for use in lactating bitches accutane amnesteem claravis or sotret cost esoproto 20 mg cialis do you need a prescription to buy levitra allegra printing in battle creek patagonia fugitive jacket womens reviews on cialis brand viagra online australia visa benadryl safe toddler best deals on cialis in canada ramipril 10 mg spc college omeprazole ratiopharm 20 mg hintay lasix vs generic furosemide hace falta receta para comprar viagra ponstan rd nombre generico de lotrisone tamiflu 75 mg posologia bactrim topamax use for bipolar disorder stopping zoloft 25 mg price of clopidogrel bisulfate pms finasteride 5mg review viagra retail cost milligram haloperidol 5 mg 1 ml actonel price canada glyburide 2 5 mg d zandu vigorex ingredients in benadryl best use of ibuprofen what does the pill meloxicam 15 mg look like capsulas redustat orlistat reviews acai berry pt mgl avionics plavix 75 mg generic canada cetirizine hydrochloride side effects ukc effexor 75 mg nedir ne fluconazole polfarmex 100 mg cena zlata fungiban ingredients in aleve bioavailability ph alendronate in vivo sun hiivatulehdus diflucan generic vardenafil from india its work novo fluvoxamine reviews buy original nolvadex in india 300 mg effexor par jour propranolol causa queda cabelo ondansetron odt 4 mg used for mode of action of metformin in hindi costruire guinzaglio cordarone cipro ophthalmic drops in ear what is ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tablets amoxicillin 500 mg and morning after pill zyvox 600 mg precio where can you buy permethrin indocin 50 mg suppository mold kalpnath rai in aap ki adalat arun amoxicillin 500 mg instructions relafen liquid metoprolol succinate best time to take does liquid cialis work and how does it work is amlodipine safe in breastfeeding can you take benadryl two days in a row amlodipine besylate 2,5 mg what is the main ingredient in cialis augmentin in typhoid treatment zyvox 600 mg iv coupons dostinex apteka online warszawa where can i buy kamagra in dubai fucidin h cream generic name buy pharmacy online buy accutane propranolol costco wholesale cabergoline sale online atenolol mylan 25 mg fluoxetine hcl 10 mg for pmdd medications how to take liquid clomid after winny generic for adapalene gel buy isotretinoin gel online clopidogrel tablets ip 75 mg used clothing enalapril 25 mg para que sirve pediatric gi specialists in glendale az effect of motilium in pregnancy amoxicillin ratioph. 1000 mg womens reviews on cialis doxazosin side effects in elderly buy beclomethasone dipropionate inhaler cost martex bula 5 mg lexapro viagra on paypal in canada omeprazole 40 mg capsule walmart fosamax price in pakistan contact keppra 500 ml beaker ofloxacin in the wellbutrin tablets cut in half generic colcrys 0.6 mg sundown hoodia 57 review seroquel 300 milligrams to ml price benzac ac india india propecia generic levitra 10 mg propiedades does prednisone cause muscle atrophy in dogs is terbinafine safe for diabetics ibuprofen 600 mg abbott estradiol levels postmenopausal women cardura cr 4 mg erste banka srbija provera stanja where to purchase acai berry tamoxifeno cinfa 20 mg prospecto onde comprar diovan com desconto metformin in hemodialysis latest in lithium battery technology aripiprazole license uk clonamox 500 mg amoxicillin pregnant dog ambenyl ingredients in aleve costo cialis 2 5 mg tamsulosin 0.4 mg for kidney stones brand name of domperidone in bangladesh is there sulfur in prednisone price of xenical in philippines generic viagra sampler generic venlafaxine good effexor when is generic cialis available in us allopurinol to buy purim holiday traditions in italy dejar usar ventolin low dose naltrexone 4 5 mg ne dirajte mi ravnicu how much does ramipril 5mg cost ias officer in aap ki adalat narendra 500 mg metronidazole alcohol monthly cost of wellbutrin prometrium 100 mg every other day best price generic viagra canada legal viagra paypal valsartan hctz 160 25 reviews low priced prescription viagra voltaren emulgel in schwangerschaft fincar hereisthebestin overnight sumatriptan 50 mg efectos secundarios b drug price propecia how to display long error message in gabapentin cialis 10mg price micardis plus 80 25 mg side effects casodex sales viagra and super viagra for sale diltiazem powder in vaseline how long can you safely take prilosec will generic abilify price drop meloxicam bestellen vigadexa gotas generico do viagra trazodone side effects ukc titrating off of topamax and ringing in the ears can buy viagra beijing xenical generic buy china paroxetine cr price apes in rapid dosierung ciprofloxacin time day best take luvox amoxil rate in karachi diltiazem 240 mg xr rosuvastatin nhs cost alginato de calcio donde comprar viagra what should i expect if i take a 20 mg cialis what is the best face wash to use with tretinoin ibuprofen 400 mg one or two tablets criminels nazis celebrex generic release voltarol patches boots chemist venta de cialis 5 mg bupropion 150 mg alcohol cefpodoxime proxetil tablets msds material safety mobiconnect debit voltaren sr 100 mg tabletki wczesnoporonne order toprol xl online micardis 40 mg en espanol 50 mg prednisone taper for poison cheap cipro without prescription naproxen in korea generic substitute altace generic for plavix in india omeprazole 40 mg nebenwirkungen antibiotika levitra prices american pharmacies pms finasteride reviews cheapest place to buy lamisil at cream 30 grams online c gabapentin 6 in lipoderm cream parcel delivery to canada cheap viagra wieviel kostet viagra in polen generic levitra cost at walmart safe to cut lexapro in half atorlip 20 cipla ltd india forum effexor 37.5 mg prednisone 40 mg acetylsalicylic acid in aspirin tablets labcorp difference between generic viagra viagra viagra for sale with american express card danazol ladogal onde comprar repelente mometasone furoate 0 1 buy get 1 escitalopram oxalate generic lexapro atarax 10 mg uso fda approved generic versions of blood thinner plavix what are the reviews for cialis professional capazo de benicar generic equivalent cheapest dilantin zyprexa guercmorteo price methotrexate in lupus escitalopram 5 mg dose laloo yadav in aap ki adalat rajat co je lepsie ako viagra online when does losartan go generic buy effexor xr 150 brand name levitra sale clingard clindamycin phosphate gel cost celexa 200 mg ulotka lidl fludrocortisone acetate tablet 0 1 mg viagra generico online contrassegno telematico is there a generic for glucovance alaway inactive ingredients in nexium who will let me use paypal to buy cialis knorr vegetable stock cubes ingredients in benadryl norvasc 10 mg cenac contre indication casodex generic price for clomid injections methocarbamol 500mg generic venlafaxine 75 mg er for tinnitus alternative medicine viagra india where can i buy viagra without a doctor best time to take flexeril and elavil diltiazem 24hr er 180 mg side effects acquistare levitra generico online thesaurus mechanism action of acyclovir in pityriasis rosea sotalol 80 mg bijsluiter medrol usar cytotec yahoo lisinopril order online without prescription jobs in ceftin merseyside uk 850 mg metformin pcos weight generic cialis 10mg rose pharmacy viagra in surrey pravastatin 20mg price blowing your nose after flonase generic enema de lactulose encefalopatia hepatica causas viagra tablets available in coimbatore cipro 500 mg ka? para can i buy cialis over the counter in orlando lasix 40 mg einnehmen low progesterone in females ginsters peppered steak slice ingredients in aleve price doxycycline tablets evecare ingredients in milk celin vitamin c tablet 500 mg naproxen apo propranolol 40 mg tablet mydocalm pastille prospect 150 mg viagra atacand tab 32 mg of caffeine my 9 lb dog swallowed a 200 mg ibuprofen where in soho buy viagra prilosec in spain thuoc grepid 75 mg wellbutrin is lasix safe to take while breastfeeding clindamycin 300 mg frequency fexofenadine hydrochloride drugbank 18v lithium cordless drill reviews best hamans ears purim orlistat generico indicaciones price of viagra in india cost in rupess giazo generic lexapro zithromax 150 mg risperdal authorized generic drug sumatriptan safe for breastfeeding tirosint inactive ingredients in levothyroxine generic zenegra overnight shipping ventolin nebules price uk rellenong pusit ingredients in benadryl cialis deutsche generika pyridium over the counter azo uti cyproheptadine brand name in pakistan karachi doxazosin cardura tablet 4 mg propranolol gry 10 mg migräne nexium gra 40 mg dr viagra for sale in baguio city milky dress the white ingredients in aleve wellbutrin sr 150mg tablets sale fluoxetine 40 mg tablets fluoride active ingredient in prozac reviews luvox panic disorder dapoxetine bertibarots cost cymbalta 30 mg tb bnf online aspirin what is the cost of viagra in winnipeg mb. zestril sale propecia 5 mg hair loss impurities in aspirin synthesis viagra without a doctor prescription australia oxycodone without acetaminophen mg meloxicam carisoprodol genericode levitra 10 mg eczane fiyat? come usare prometrium in gravidanza prednisone overdose in canines reminyl er 16 mg precious metal prices zuvamor vs crestor generic equivalent u.s.a. crusade for viagra cialis what is work of this in hindi metronidazole tablets colgout 500 mg metformin there cheaper alternative lipitor inactive ingredients in liquid gabapentin aspirin plus c 400 mg beipackzettel ciprofloxacin ramipril buy order viagra nepal cialis without prescription in uae furosemide tab 20 mg abilify howdotofound discount losartan cinfa 100 mg albendazole tablets in pregnancy cut omeprazole in half lopid generico de cialis lexapro generic heart palpitations best place buy viagra online uk viagra orodispersibile costo clopidogrel ppi canada marketing of benadryl cough syrup bupropion to stop smoking reviews on windows periactin online bestellen met canada pharmacy generic clomid 50mg digoxin in right ventricular failure prandin 1 mg comprimidos gastrorresistentes what will happen if i take 2 ibuprofen 800 mg is viagra over the counter new york tesco artane bank holiday opening hours donde comprar propecia colombia metformin sandoz is it a generic brand discount aggrenox trazodone 10 mg bijsluiter lasix 20 mg how long does it take to work crackzapit ingredients in aleve proscar 1 25 mg andare in cipro viagra dove comprare 300 mg of seroquel









Saudi Reforms, Saudi Crackdowns

By Jamie Glazov | November 7, 2003


See especially the policy prescriptions at the end of this article

Saudi Arabia's rulers are now paying lip-service to supporting an experiment with a Gorbachev-like program of Perestroika and Glasnost. But are they serious? If they are, why did they recently crackdown on reform demonstrators? And if the political system were to be "opened up," wouldn't there be a danger that Taliban-like fanatics would just gain more power? Moreover, what does Saudi "reform" even mean if the Saudis continue to foment their hate against America and Israel in their mosques and classrooms? And what policy should the Bush administration be pursuing toward these Saudi realities?


To discuss these and other aspects regarding Saudi Arabia today, Frontpage Symposium is joined by Khalid Al-Dakhil, an assistant professor of political sociology at King Saud University in Saudi Arabia. He has been a columnist for London's Al Hayat newspaper and is now a visiting fellow at the Carnegie Endowment in DC; Andrew Apostolou, Director of Research at the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies, a policy institute created after 9/11 and focusing on terrorism; Laurent Murawiec, Laurent Murawiec, a former Seniolr Rand Corp. analyst  is now a Senior Fellow with the Hudson Institute. His book on Saudi Arabia, "Taking Saudi out of Arabia" ["La Guerre d'apres"] came out last month in Paris; and Kenneth R. Timmerman, an investigative reporter and author who has spent twenty years reporting on Europe and the Middle East. His latest book, Preachers of Hate: Islam and the War on America, raises serious questions about Saudi government funding of terror and Saudi funding of radical Wahhabi preachers and schools that are training new generations of Muslims to hate Jews and hate America. He is also the author of Shakedown: Exposing the Real Jesse Jackson, and The Death Lobby: How the West Armed Iraq, and writes regularly for Insight Magazine. Information on his latest book and recent articles are available at;


Interlocutor: Welcome gentlemen to Frontpage Symposium. It is a pleasure to have you here. Let's begin with this question: Are the recently announced Saudi "reforms" credible? And if there is going to be a successful "reform movement" in Saudi Arabia, is it going to be led by Saudis wanting more democracy, or by fanatics who want more Talibanization?


Al-Dakhil: The first part of your question assumes that the announced reforms are unprecedented. Well, they are not. There were such reform before, I mean municipal election, as far back as 1965. And what was announced few weeks ago was simply a revival of a law that was decreed by the late king Khalid in 1979. That law was about administrative and legal reforms at the municipal level. So on that basis, it could easily be said that the announced reforms are credible indeed. But, the real question should be about whether this announcement is the beginning of a real and comprehensive reform plan that would include political, economic, and constitutional reforms? Or simply another attempt at going back to the old game of starting something, then leaving it suffocate under the laws of bureaucracy and time.




The second part of the question is loaded and suggestive, as so many things that are being said about Saudi Arabia in the US capital these days. Not all religious oriented people are like Taliban. And it should be stressed here that Taliban belong to a different Islamic school of law, i.e. the Hanafi school, from the one followed by the majority in Saudi Arabia, i.e. the Hanbali school. I expect us to go back to this later on during our dialogue.


I don't expect the fanatics to win the election in Saudi Arabia. However, it's almost certain that the conservatives, both from the religious and the tribal circles, will dominate such elections. This is natural and expected, considering that the society has been exposed for so long to one perspective, i.e., the conservative religious perspective. But then, there's nothing wrong with the conservative wining the election. After all, election and freedom is for all, and not only for the liberals and the progressives. The most important is to start the reform, institute freedom of expression and pluralism. That way the society's floor will be opened to different point views, and the people will be exposed to more than one discourse. After that they'll have more than one choice to make. 


Apostolou: The just announced proposed changes, one hesitates to call them "reforms", are a belated regime response to internal and external pressure. There was a similar response following the 1991 Gulf War. The question that one has to ask is what does the ruling family want to get out of these changes? It is rather unlikely that they want to emancipate their subjects and turn them into citizens. Indeed, it is implausible that the ruling family, which is rather like a vast, sprawling conglomerate, would surrender any real power. It is more likely that they want to co-opt elements of the population that they fear may move from indifference towards opposition.


There are various currents of opposition calling for change in Saudi Arabia and there has long been opposition to the ruling family. These currents of opinion are diverse, fractious and in some rather famous cases, more extreme than the clerical establishment which provides religious legitimacy to the ruling regime. How strong these currents are, however, is hard to tell given how closed Saudi Arabia is to even the people who live there, let alone outsiders. Political trends within society, let alone the ruling family, are difficult to get a handle on.




It is also worth remembering that it was Saudi Arabia which helped to fund and train the Taliban (Pakistan provided manpower, military support and training, the UAE made a cash contribution), so arguably the Taliban went through "Saudi-isation". Al-Qaida, which is now attacking targets in Saudi Arabia, therefore counts as a "returned export" rather than an "import".


Timmerman: I would go even further than Andrew Apostolou. There was not merely a "Saudiasation" of the Taliban; the Taliban where a Saudi creation. They were educated at madrassas in Pakistan that had been built with Saudi money and were staffed with wahhabi clerics sent on mission by the Saudi government. While in power, their regime was propped up by non-stop deliveries of Saudi wheat and Saudi cash. (I witnessed one of those convoys blocking the border beyond Peshawar in March 1998; it stretched more than a mile long, bumper to bumper).

The Saudis modeled the system they set up in Pakistan to train the Taliban on their own state-run schools. The Saudi national Education Policy doctrine, translated recently by the Center for Monitoring the Impact of Peace, states that "the purpose of education is understanding Islam correctly and completely, implanting and spreading the Islamic faith, providing the student with Islamic values, instructions and ideals…" Among those Islamic values is "jihad," the doctrine states. "Jihad in God's cause is a firm religious duty, a norm to be followed and an existing necessity. It is to continue [so] until the Day of Resurrection."

It will be very difficult, if not impossible, for "reformers" to emerge from within the Saudi system until the Saudis reform the school system that continues to teach hatred of Jews, hatred of Western values and hatred of the West as its basic values. In fifth grade, students are given this "yes-no" quiz:

¤ "The religion of Islam is the path that leads to Paradise."

¤ The other religions destroy their followers."

In ninth grade, students are taught, "There is no doubt that the Muslims' power irritate the infidels and spread envy in the hearts of the enemies of Islam &endash; Christians, Jews and others… a malicious Crusader-Jewish alliance [is] striving to eliminate Islam from all the continents."

Dramatic changes in the Saudi school curricula should be the first measure of the credibility of any reform. Why have we never heard the Saudis even mention this?

Murawiec: It is the umpteenth time that "reforms" are announced. Take none of it seriously. It is a useful rabbit to take out of the royal hat every time the outside world has to be impressed. Periodically the alcoholic announces that he intends to reform himself. The al-Saud are addicted to power and its perks and the wealth it gives them. Going cold turkey is not something the regime is able, let alone willing to do. The gullibility of foreigners makes that talk into headlines. In 1975 municipal elections were announced. Today they're talking of electing half the councils in 14 municipalities…


The al-Saud-Wahhabi nexus has created a monstrous creature, as an extension of itself: decades of brainwashing of youth to a doctrine that is inherently nihilistic, that preaches enmity toward and destruction of "apostates and schismatics" (Shiites) "apes and pigs" (Christians and Jews), hatred for the West. The doctrine and the associated practices have not remained internal but have been massively exported. As a result, what is happening inside Saudi Arabia has ceased to be an internal Saudi affair: it is an urgent danger for the world. Since the Saudi regime is Talibans with oil - the Talibans were Saudis without oil -   there is a serious danger. If need be it should be pre-empted. The al-Saud-Wahhabi nexus has taken over most Sunni extremist (fundamentalist, revivalist) movements in the world over the last few decades: Moslem Brotherhood, Deobandi, Tablighi, etc. What matters is not whether they are Hanafi or Hanbali, but that they have been "Wahhabized."


If we're talking reform, the reintroduction of the three other major Sunni madhdhab in Mecca and of the Shiites should be a priority. Moslem pluralism sounds like a good beginning. It was the case from time immemorial and was only abolished, in blood and violence, in 1925, when ibn Saud and the Ikhwan conquered Hijaz.


Democracy is not a matter of elections. Elections are the crowning, last chapter of democratic development. Rule of law, equality for all, legal and civil rights, transparent governance, accountability of those who hold office &endash; that's what begins democracy. Saddam's Iraq, Assad's Syria, Mubarak's Egypt have had plenty of elections &endash; a sham.




Interlocutor: So if the announced reforms are just a sham, the crackdown really shouldn't be a surprise, right? What exactly was the scope of the crackdown anyway?


Al-Dakhil: Demonstrations are prohibited by law in Saudi Arabia. So crackdowns should be expected by a regime that is not used to the idea of the people going out to demonstrate as a way of expressing their views and grievances. As to the scope, it seems to be big. Official figures of those who were arrested is put at more than 150. Unofficial figures is much more than that.


Apostolou: The structure of Saudi politics is an ongoing crackdown. North Korea is sometimes referred to as the "Hermit Kingdom". The same could be said of Saudi Arabia, a country largely closed to outside analysts and whose political system is opaque. There is always repression in Saudi Arabia. Arguably what defines a "crackdown" is when the regime goes after genuinely dangerous people and publicizes its pursuit of these extremists. During late 2001 and 2002 the attitude towards Saudi nationals returning from Afghanistan was lax. Many were briefly detained and interrogated, too few remained in jail.




Murawiec: The al-Saud don't like to lose face: they did with the Riyadh explosions. They did with the recent demonstration. It is a totalitarian society tempered by tribalism. So they crack down. The problem is that, beyond the street extremists, they would have to arrest themselves. Prince Nayef, prince Sultan, Prince Turki, to name but a few very senior members of the royal family, have been involved at the highest level in the establishment, the sustenance and the action of terrorist organizations. The feedback loop has been reaching Arabia ever since Turki's protégé bin Laden first returned from Afghanistan. Note also that there is a continuum rather than a gap between the regime and their "opponents." Arab politics is never simple. Saudi affairs are never wysiwyg. You'll see an opponent, a dissenting faction, maintaining contact with and receiving support from some senior member of the Royals or a member of his Majlis.


There is a proper context to assess all that: the succession struggle. Who will be king, who wil be crown prince, who will be next in line? Understand, none of the contenders if "pro-American" or "anti," they're only pro-al Saud, and they play the American card as opportunity dictates. But the succession is played like succession struggles in closed societies, late Soviet Union or last years of Mao: never look at the face of the conjuror, look at his hands and fingers. It is now the various shows that matter, what happens on the front-stage of the theater, but the backstage maneuvering, negotiations, back-stabbings, etc. The family is coming down the wire. All major factions have tried to postpone crucial decisions in the hope of gathering more factional power, more allies, and position themselves better. Time is running out. We should expect more eruptions, none of which will be dictated by "popular" sentiment, all of which will be the expression of court and clan factions.


Timmerman: Khalid al-Dakhil is right: why should we be surprised if the Saudis arrest rural clerics who might stir up the population against their rule &endash; especially when those clerics are Shias, whom they consider as "heretics"? More significant would be the replacement of government clerics such as Sheikh Saad al Buraik, who raised $109 million last year for the families of suicide bombers and had this to say on Saudi state television: "I am against America until this life ends, until the Day of Judgment… O Muslim Ummah, don't take the Jews and Christians as allies." (p119-120, Preachers of Hate).

Interlocutor: Fair enough gentlemen, but hasn't there been some kind of general "shift,"  or an "evolution," in Saudi policies? 

Dakhil: The question is so general that I'm not sure what you mean; internal or foreign policies. If what you have in mind is the internal policy, then I would say that there are signs that a shift or an evolution is about to take place. The crown prince, Abdullah Ibn Abdul-Aziz, is talking about expanding political participation. And it is significant to note here that he is the first in the ruling family, and in such a high position, to ever use the expression "political participation". Education is being reformed. Promises have been made to go beyond municipal elections. These are a mixed bag of promises and signs on the one hand, and real steps on the ground, on the other. However, considering the fact that the society on the basis of which the state was created is different now in many ways than what it use to be in the past, and considering the challenges the Saudis are facing now, both internal external, makes political shifts, or reforms the only option available.

Apostolou: It took the al-Qaida attacks in May for the ruling family to recognize that they have a terrorism problem. Until then, they thought that they only had a PR problem. Americans, having suffered 3,000 casualties courtesy of the Saudi terrorism problem, thought otherwise.

Until these attacks the measures taken to curb both incitement to terrorism and the funding of terrorism were largely geared towards appeasing the US. The perception within the kingdom was, accurately, that the terrorism is a threat to others. The ruling family knows that it has to change in some way, but is unsure what to do. After all, it does not want to lose its control of power and wealth. We have had hints of possible change coming out of the ruling family in the past and they have always come to very little.

Timmerman: Andrew Apostolou is right, in my view, to emphasize the importance of the Riyadh bombings this May. The Saudis claimed the bombings created a popular backlash against al Qaeda, and helped dry up recruitment. They also claim they prompted the government to take a hard look at their approach toward terror. But we have very few windows into the hearts and minds of ordinary Saudis other than what the Saudi government wants to provide us, and this should give us pause, especially as the Saudi media and Saudi schools continue to preach a doctrine of hate &endash; hatred of Jews, hatred of Christians, hatred of all those who do not embrace their militant faith.

Murawiec: Change? Dunes change every day as the wind dictates. In closed systems, like totalitarian regimes, biology is the prime factor of direct change - King Fahd is clinically dead but not politically. Pressures mount from within and from without. The al-Saud are poorly able to perceive pressures (everything is a threat) and to adjust and adapt - their modus operandi is to buy, cajole, threaten, arrest, torture, kill - not to devise new policies.

While the art of survival has been the only conspicuous talent of the al-Sauds (with consumption, I hasten to add), I wonder if they haven't entered what ibn Khaldun calls the "fourth [dynastic] generation" which squanders the legacy of its forebears - except that doom would come with the fourth king, not even the fourth generation.


Interlocutor: Ok, so what do we make of the reported nuclear deals and ambitions the Saudis are engaged in? They are brewing trouble aren't they?

Murawiec: Saudi Arabia has been pursuing a nuclear option for years. The kingdom desires nukes all the more urgently that the 60-year window of partnership with the U.S. is closing. The royals want nukes to acquire a strategic immunity &endash; which they once enjoyed under the American umbrella. They funded both Saddam's nuclear program, pre-1991, and Pakistan. Their "buy me a country" policy concerned Pakistan in the first place, since Ali Bhutto and Zia ul-Haq. The "Islamic Bomb" Islamabad bragged of was the financial offspring of Riyad. The transfer of designs, technologies and material both in the nuclear and in the ballistic sectors have been intense between China, North Korea, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia &endash; it all started with the sale of China's Silkworm missiles to Saudi Arabia. Both Pakistan's nuclear and ballistic programs have been godfathered by the Saudis. Crown Prince Abdullah's mid-October state visit was concerned with this in priority. 


Timmerman: Already in the mid-1980s, Saudi Arabia, with U.S. help, began building a series of deep underground bases that were designed to withstand a nuclear attack. From Communist China, the Saudis purchased long-range missiles capable of carrying a nuclear warhead. In both cases, the Saudis claimed they were responding to a threat from the Islamic Republic of Iran. That is what they are doing today. The Saudi response to Iran's nuclear weapons ambitions should demonstrate the extraordinary folly of the Non-proliferation Treaty, which in essence legitimates and even enhances clandestine nuclear weapons development in aspiring nuclear weapons states by encouraging the nuclear powers to transfer technology to them behind the fig leaf of civilian nuclear cooperation. As every nuclear engineer, physicist and weapons designer I have ever interviewed has told me, shifting from civilian nuclear power to nuclear weapons is like crossing the street with the light. It is time to impose far more draconian controls on all nuclear technology transfers than those that currently exist.

Apostolou: The Saudis are interested in a nuclear option for obvious reasons (Patrick Clawson at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy has written well on this matter). They do not, however, appear to be particularly advanced towards such a capability. They have potential delivery systems but nothing to deliver. There has been speculation that Pakistan would hand Saudi Arabia a bomb if it needed it and the irresponsible way in which Pakistan behaves with its nuclear technology gives credibility to such speculation. Much will depend on how the EU and IAEA deal with Iran in coming months. My personal suspicion is that they will, at best, delay the Iranian programme, but no more. In the meantime, one expects that the Saudis will consider other options, such as repairing their relations with the US. Despite the problems in Saudi-US relations, Saudi Arabia needs the US to be its security guarantor. The Saudi desire to have that guarantee reaffirmed gives the US important leverage which it should use.

Interlocutor: In terms of everything I am hearing from you gentlemen, it looks like Saudi Arabia is our enemy. The heavy indoctrination of the Saudi youth by the Mullas preaching hate for Americans, Jews, and all things Western is evidence enough. What kind of friends are these?

Murawiec: the essential point is that nothing and nobody can split or separate Wahhabi from al-Saud. They have been business and clanic-family partners since the mid-18th century! Wahhabi ideology is intrinsic to the power of the al-Saud, the might of the al-Saud the key to the survival and spread of Wahhabism. The doctrine itself is a backward, desert-bound, simplistic mish-mash of pagan mores and practices with Islamic slogans. It is intrinsically a violent and ruthlessly-bigoted doctrine. This is reflected in the sermons, the schoolbooks, the fatwas and juridico-religious debates in the kingdom. The al-Saud-Wahhabi nexus has a layered view of a divinely-ordered hierarchy of beings: the worst are the Chiite "apostates and schismatics," the Jews are just an inch above, below Christians who are hated. Non-Wahhabi Moslems are not much above, all of them way down the food chain on top of which the Saudi Royals have established their seats. The West is inherently an enemy to be destroyed. In the Bedouin way of war, you only wage battle if and when you can win it. Otherwise, bid your time and strike as soon as you may. Infidels anew to be destroyed. Some friends.

Timmerman: The United States is walking a tightrope in our relations with the Saudi royal family. To one side, we see the criminal behavior of senior Saudi princes, who sponsor the preachers of hate, export Wahhabism, and who in some cases continue to provide financial support to Osama Bin Laden and to the network of charities and commercial entities that feed him. On the other, lies Bin Laden himself. The Saudis like to remind us that what comes after them is far worse. While that may be true, the Saudis have consciously created the swamps that lie on either side of the tightrope. I detail in Preachers of Hate how the Saudis, starting with King Fahd in person, made a pact with the devil starting in 1979 to export wahhabism around the world in order to protect them from the wahhabis at home. As part of that pact, they have failed to educate their population, or instill in them the values that would allow them to navigate the modern world as responsible (and peaceful) citizens. They have failed to create a middle class of skilled professionals; they have failed to empower half of their population (women). Indeed, for all their hundreds of billions of dollars in oil revenues since 1979, the Saudi royal family have failed to create a single monument to civilization, unless you count pleasure palace King Fahd has built on the French Riviera near Monaco that is so vast it takes a commercial jet five full minutes to fly beyond it.

Apostolou: Many countries indoctrinate schoolchildren with varying degrees of success. By contrast, in Britain, we attempt to bore children to death in school. So why does indoctrination in Saudi Arabia matter to the US? The answer is because it has helped to fuel terrorism and encourages people to fund terrorism. It is not just that 15 of the 19 September 11 hijackers were Saudi nationals, but that around half of the 660 inmates of Guantanamo Bay are also Saudi nationals. The problem we have, however, is that indoctrination alone does not lead to terrorism. After all, some millions have been exposed to the sort of inflammatory and chauvinistic ideas that Americans have now realized are part of a Saudi education, but the number of terrorists is in the thousands. The population of Saudi Arabia is around 22 million (5 million foreigners, 17 million Saudi nationals), of which probably 20% is composed of native males under the age of 15. The implication of the incitement argument is that there are 3.4 million potential terrorists being bred. If that is the case, then our problems have only just begun. Similarly, it is worth remembering that while Saudi Arabia sells many tens of billions of dollars of oil each year, the amount of money that finds its way from Saudi nationals to terrorists is in the millions (for the sake of argument, if Saudi Arabia exports 8m b/d for $25/b, that is $73 billion per annum. Al-Qaida's annual budget before September 11 was estimated at some $30 million, some of which did not come from Saudi sources). Most of this money comes from individuals, some of whom are readily identifiable.

What the US therefore needs to do is to make its relationship with Saudi Arabia contingent upon specific and verifiable reforms: ending incitement and religious chauvinism sponsored by the state, a programme of serious interdiction of financing for terrorism, an end to the variable and sometimes "kid gloves" treatment handed out to terrorists. Non-Americans have additional concerns. The Middle East has suffered from the way in which Saudi Arabia uses its money to encourage intolerance and to stifle debate: whether it is the support for the families of terrorists who murder Israelis, the encouragement of extremists in Algeria or the buying up of the Arabic press in London. The US should certainly push for such alterations in Saudi behaviour, but US allies in the Middle East will also have to pipe up. All such measures will assist in the war against terrorism, but they will not be the "magic bullet" that defeats terrorism.

Interlocutor: Tomorrow Colin Powell resigns for some reason and you are appointed Secretary of State. In your first meeting with the President, he tells you that you two are the Nixon-Kissinger duo part II. He wants to mould a brilliant foreign policy toward Saudi Arabia and to manipulate it to help win the War on Terror. He asks you the first basic steps he should start taking. What do you say?

Timmerman: First, Mr. President, we must be clear about the origins of terror. Terror does not draw its powerful attraction from poverty and underdevelopment, despite what the French say (they could give two hoots about poverty and underdevelopment &endash; but that's another story). Terror has sprung like a vine from roots plunged deep into a sewer of hate. We cannot just pull up the vine, Mr. President. We have to empty the sewer.

The Saudi royal family is the main sponsor of this sewer of hate, by nurturing and financing a radical vision of Islam which uses Jew-hatred and the hatred of Western values to destroy the rational minds of the young. When your enemies are the "sons of monkeys and pigs," as the Saudis and their friends in Gaza, Jerusalem, Cairo and Damascus preach every Friday, it becomes much easier to murder them. Oh, and by the way: in the minds of these preachers of hate, we are all Jews, so there is no escaping their fate. 

Our goal, Mr. President, should be nothing less than to spark a reformation within the world of Islam; just repeating that Islam is a "religion of peace" that has been "hijacked by murderers" is not enough. The Saudis can either take the lead in the reformation, as the Custodians of the Two Holy mosques, or they can be beaten by it. That is the choice you should put to them.

You must make clear that there is no middle ground in the war on terror. If the Saudis want to be with us, they must: 1) cut off funding to the preachers of hate, both inside the Kingdom and abroad, 2) change the curricula in their schools to reflect a reformed vision of Islam as a "religion of peace" for the living, not an appeal to the peace of the graveyard, 3) close down the so-called "Islamic banks" that are financing Bin Laden and his ilk, 4) confiscate the assets of the princes and non-royal families who have provided financial assistance to Bin Laden.

Yes, you can make this pitch quietly by inviting Crown Prince Abdallah to the ranch &endash;once. But you must make clear, Mr. President, that these are not subjects of discussion. These are demands. And there must be clear deadlines.

Prince Abdallah will complain that he must have something to take back to his people to make them swallow this hard pill (such as putting "pressure" on Israel). Here you must be inflexible. He should be happy to keep his throne. This is the price for that. You should remind him that the modern, moderate representative government we have helped build in Iraq could serve as a natural attraction to the Shias of Saudi Arabia's eastern province. If he doesn't get the hint, try these words: the Republic of Aramco.

And as far as the Middle East peace "process" goes, Mr. President: If you decide to use all the tools at our disposal (such as making money vanish as it is being wired into the wrong bank accounts), that poor excuse for university sinecures and State Department diplomacy will join the graveyard of bad ideas where it belongs.

There is one serious downside to pursuing this policy you must consider, however: it will generate massive unemployment in the ranks of the State Department Arabists. Maybe that's why they have never proposed a serious policy that is in America's interest to you before.


Murawiec: Sxteen months ago, I told exactly that to the Defense Policy Board, and the Washington Post featured it one month later. I've developed it in my book La Guerre d'après which just appeared in Paris: we need to issue a detailed ultimatum to the Saudis. If there are any "Gorbachevs" in the royal family, let them stand up and be counted. If the terms of our ultimatum are obeyed, it will be a giant step forward in the War on Terrorism &endash; finances, propaganda, indoctrination, logistics, cadres, Saudi intel, etc. If not, the very logic of the War is that we tackle the Saudi royals, very rudely. But one thing needs to be clear: the time for finessing and being oh! so clever with the Saudis is over. They don't get it. You're either top dog or low dog. Let's not try to "manipulate" them: let's roll.


Apostolou: Sorry, but I am not a US citizen and my current visa does not permit me to take government employment.


Interlocutor: Ok Mr. Apostolou, but when you can take employment you better get in touch with me for a new symposium on this subject. In any case, thank you Mr. Apostolou, and thank you Kenneth Timmerman, Laurent Murawiec and Khalid Al-Dakhil. It was a honor to have all of you here with us. Take care for now.


I welcome all of our readers to get in touch with me if they have a good idea for a symposium. Email me at



Islamic Anti-Semitism. Guests: Kenneth R. Timmerman, Bat Ye'or, Walid Phares and Robert Spencer

Pakistan -- Friend or Foe? Guests: Timothy D. Hoyt, Walid Phares, Alex Alexiev, Esam Sohail.

The Muslim Persecution of Christians. Guests: Bat Ye'or, Paul Marshall, Habib Malik and Walid Phares.

What About Syria? Guests: Alex Alexiev, Nir Boms, Bassam Haddad and David Kaiser.

Original article



Upcoming Media events

From the author of the national best-seller, Shakedown!



Like no other book before it, Preachers of Hate uncovers an ancient hatred that threatens the life and livelihood of every American.

The "new" anti-Semitism targets not only Jews, but Americans.

It targets our values, our lifestyle, and our freedoms.

Middle East Data Project, Inc.,

7831 Woodmont Ave - Suite 395ßßß

Bethesda, MD 20814