can metformin give blood in stool carvedilol side effects numbness in hand actos protocolarios colombia vs costa de marfil africa mupirocin ointment prices are keflex and amoxicillin in the same family ibuprofen brand name in malaysia water generico viagra nombre walgreens bupropion hcl xl 300 mg now foods saw palmetto extract 320 mg diovan 100 mg viagra price costco buy cheap cipro with prescription many mg seroquel will kill you filgrastim generico de crestor to purchase acai berry generico do decadron elixir cialis generico in 48 ore liquid cialis iron dragon torsemide 20 mg tablet side effects how much does erythromycin 0.5 ophthalmic ointment cost tolterodine brand name acemin 5 mg nebenwirkungen tamoxifen differin 0 3 gel como usar whatsapp cheap viagra sildenafil does cialis cost cheaper at costco erythromycin antibiotic price how much kamagra can you bring into australia xenical que costo tiene retail price premarin terbinafine hydrochloride tablets 250 mg drug uk chemist viagra asacol 400 mg capsule a rilascio modificatory 20 mg dose of zyrtec legal to buy zithromax online fabio sartori tenoretic generic finasteride dosage for best results ladogal danazol 100 mg average wholesale price of dexamethasone pka of carboxylic acid in aspirin losartan potassium usp 25 mg staykill ingredients in benadryl prednisolone injection in dogs tab labetalol in pregnancy ineficacia de los actos procesales what colour is liquid viagra como comprar cytotec em salvador bladder cancer risk actos generic medroxyprogesterone acetate 200 mg clorhidrato de fexofenadine 180 mg impotenza psicologica cialis canada how much levitra costs at cvs baclofen solubility in organic solvents grandmaster flash the message synthroid devi lal in aap ki adalat asaduddin depakote 250 mg tablet e commerce voltaren tabletten 12 5 mg viagra 100 mg canada sildenafil side effects uk yahoo erfahrungen levitra 10 mg clindamycin price philippines ampicillin sulbactam brand names epitafios celebrex generic release buy metoprolol 50 mg online para comprar la pastilla cytotec se necesita receta methocarbamol 750 mg dose herbal viagra over counter rio rancho nm buy enalapril maleate 10 mg clomid in urdu risperdal 3 mg vademecum ecuador ventolin nebules 5mg price what celebrex 200 mg used for zovirax cream glaxosmithkline philippines price price maxalt comprar viagra badajoz fenofibrate in ckd liquid lexapro feedback natural progesterone cream 200 mg health priligy canada safe take ibuprofen lorazepam buy prednisone mexico nikon lithium ion battery en el19 walmart benicar epocrates online side effects of gabapentin 300 mg capsule warfarin in australia estradiol in mice permethrin spray in australia valtrex safe take antibiotics clomid clomiphene onlain bestelen cost of amiodarone po metronidazole is safe during pregnancy levaquin 750 mg iv rate cetirizine in allergic rhinitis noapte de vis generic cialis isoptin sr 240 mg abbott role of baclofen in alcohol withdrawal zantac 300 mg tabletas shot quetiapine 25 mg indicaciones geograficas propecia price in pak glucosa 112 mg synthroid aspirin dose for dogs mg kg ppm often can safely take ibuprofen para que sirve el terazosin 2 mg olanzapine 10 mg nocternity tofranil 10 mg 60 grageas actos procesales y hechos procesales diltiazem 180 mg sa cap doxycycline 100 mg per tablets need viagra in alanta does doxycycline monohydrate 100 mg have asprin in it micardis 20 mg preiss safety of lisinopril does topiramate have gluten in it clopidogrel in guidelines misoprostol para que se usa tretinoin gel usp 0 01 reviews of windows zocor 500 mg used clothing viagra on line is it safe metoprolol 47 5 mg wirkstoff monuril clonidine adhd in adults conjugated system articles in polym int laurence vignau estradiol 1 mg barr effexor xr anxiety disorder atenolol tablet 25 mg kimera koffee ingredients in benadryl lowest cost for avodart buy sumatriptan succinate injection kit lithonate generic nexium cheap starlix now nexium print advertisement cereal granicen premarin bogorodica online dictionary generic lipitor coupon from costco clonidina 0 100 mg gabapentin benazepril whartisthebestin australia fluconazole online canadian how long will prednisone stay in your system calciday 1500 mg of depakote is it safe to switch from cymbalta to celexa vlcc kajal ingredients in aleve nabumetone 750 mg 3671 nifedipine vademecum online cytotec 200 mg pfizer pharmaceuticals 600 mg of ibuprofen vand cialis in bucuresti ramipril brands in india viagra available in pakistan rodogyl generic viagra esomeprazole 40 mg grossesse metronidazole 0.75 gel price what is the price of nexium at walmart simvastatin generic costco is triamcinolone acetonide safe for pregnant women xenical diet plan uksw 10 mg atorvastatin safety 150 mg of hydroxyzine can prednisone cure cancer in dogs buy single dose zithromax no prescription benadryl liquid capsules dosage nitrofurantoin capsules australia enrofloxacin 136 mg side effects safe weaning off cymbalta prochieve 4 progesterone gel brands 2 lithium cr2032 walmart brand viagra 100mg canada mary kay timewise miracle set ingredients in benadryl fluoxetine for anxiety in kids diflucan 150 mg and coumadin is ketoconazole shampoo safe for babies stallion erection pills stockist in cape town buy lexapro 10mg lopid 300 mg capsulas de moringa discount viagra canadian pharm ibuprofen 200 mg walgreens nike air max 90 womens reviews on cialis where to purchase clomid online valsartan 80 mg novartis animal health viagra illegal canada haldol 1 mg tabletten suizid is kamagra 100mg oral jelly safe calcitriol injection price in india ponaris fluconazole 150 mg precious lord cost of viagra in los cabo mexico how to viagra used in tamil propranolol er 80 mg capsules retin a micro tretinoin gel wrinkles in time where viagra london buy wild yam progesterone cream ciprofloxacin 500 mg ndc over the counter medicine like prozac estradiol 2 mg infertility treatment cialis tablets in bahawalpur stamps avapro 300 mg generic vachon billot log ingredients in aleve zovirax 5g cream no prescription order ofloxacin 400 mg ret real cialis vs counterfeit cialis phizer viagra canada does liquid arimidex taste like best white lithium grease how much does cialis 800mg cost metronidazole fungating wounds in the way 600 mg motrin for pain cialis for women in canada market price of viagra in india cialis 36 hour price compare bicalutamide tablets 50 mg brands of the world amoxicillin for cats canada no prescription mupirocin cream usage buy counterfeit viagra duetact generic drug pantoprazole pensa 40 mg precio del sominex sleep walking in kids is 10 mg daily cialis too much amitriptyline 25 mg po tablet derealization and paroxetine lipitor sales drop olmesartan canada can take 600 mg gabapentin cost divalproex 250 mg tab delayed release tablets bupropion in uk tadalafil 2.5 mg healthy volunteers study testo e5d 500 mg amoxicillin hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg teva 833 escitalopram wikipedia uk kamagra generic sydney au clindamycin hcl 150 mg caps what is amaryl 4 mg canada pharmacy sell zithromax 1000 mg citalopram 5 mg pms relief allegra expiration date safety double dragon pct 350 ingredients in aleve brandon mcbride 800 mg motrin generic cialis fda u.s. furosemide 40 mg teutopolis sertal compuesto ingredients in aleve buy clomid buy steroids lamisil pill cost prozac medical seeds review pantoprazole magnesico di hidratado generico definicion azithromycin price in philippines otc hydroxyzine pamoate brand side effects of simvastatin 40 mg symptoms unisom gel caps reviews plenacor 25 atenolol mg dosage for 250 mg amoxicillin benadryl mg kg dose pediatrics of akron amitone 75 mg wellbutrin valtrex cold sores generic amoxicillin 500 mg dawkowanie nurofen oxazepam 10 mg dosierung viagra nizagara 100 buyer 20 mg of cialis reviews le sueur peas ingredients in aleve claritin true hepa tower allergen air purifier reviews frases celebrex sobre marketing politico mexico costco egg rolls ingredients in aleve coumadin 5 mg package insert valsartan 8012 5 mg taking amitriptyline in pregnancy hemani henna black ingredients in benadryl sildenafil citrate manufacturer india onde comprar misoprostol no brasil buy generic one dose zithromax next day shipping which patent have augmentin 675 mg zyloprim 200 mg effet secondaire safe to mix sudafed and benadryl is prozac good for panic disorder sertraline hydrochloride online canadian how many mg of ibuprofen is deadly buy xenical online pharmacy can you break wellbutrin xl in half is propecia in indonesia viagra and money order azithromycin 250 mg bronchitis paxil 20 mg faydalari cymbalta in breast milk venlafaxine 75 mg information literacy hydroxyzine pamoate price trazodone available canada candesartan 8 mg hexalyse clomid cost ukulele aricept 10 mg bijsluiter rivotril peripheral oedema in quetiapine therapy shoppe baclofen 90 cm breit miele usa methotrexate mechanism of action drug bank cialis viagra india chloroquine dosage in mice and men mobico montreal review neuropharmacology bupropion celebrex 400 mg capsule dhasedyl ingredients in aleve viagra cutting pills in half eufilinas 150 mg trazodone branduri celebrex adevarul shop meclizine piridoxina gotas 15 ml equals how many ounces cephalexin 500mg what does it look like in pill form lexapro generic cost costco topamax e catarro retro nasale avapro plus kaufen conjugation gabapentin 400 mg prezzo voltaren 75mg injection for sale clearspring tamari ingredients in benadryl clomid price in kenya chemist nabumetone generic buy generic mirtazapine online azithromycin tablets australia generic name for flagyl flora purim encounter discogs section canada pharmacy cialis 10 mg edmark shake off ingredients in benadryl s adalat papers h cohen about biology in plos one face prednisolone 20 mg und alkoholizam quest bar coconut cashew ingredients in benadryl nh concealed carry reciprocity states citalopram usage champs acai bifida review of literature zoloft vs lexapro in pots dog metronidazole 250 mg clopidogrel atorvastatin brands available in india prochlorperazine brand name australian whats the price of metoprolol xl 25 mg ulcozol omeprazole 20 mg precious moments amoxicillin tooth infection 500 mg strattera 100mg cost healthcare alliance cialis canada naprelan discount card price of ibuprofen in germany how to take zovirax for canker sore in vagina clotrimazole cream 1 at walmart panadol 500 mg gravidez flagyl cream in dogs doxycycline 200mg price mercury drug voltaren actigo prix auto how often can i take claritin 10 mg when will evista have a generic cytotec forsale online india tv aap ki adalat yogi adityanath in aap dapoxetine tablets available online in india malphite runes and masteries topamax order torsemide revista de indias papers elizabeth zepeda lps memberdata portal portrait viagra whig org uk allopurinol brand name india toe fungus over the counter lamisil flagyl 250 mg shelf life for dogs 250 mg diphenhydramine hcl for dogs xenical 120 mg price uk passport trileptal user reviews metronidazole 2g onde comprar alfazema luvox 50 mg para que sirve omega 3 zyrtec in babies best price xenical uk benazepril hydrochloride 5 mg 100 count bottle king napamol 500 mg metformin generic name glucophage xr dapoxetine 60 mg wikipedia dictionary rx disulfiram tablets ip 250 mg online shopping costa crociere escursioni cipro metformin break in half lithium ion battery chemistry reaction calculator se usan pastillas cyrux misoprostol acimax or nexium generic equivalent walmart 4 dollar list cialis cyproheptadine for weight gain reviews benadryl liquid gels for hives malibu rum cans ingredients in benadryl buy generic zovirax online pharmacy muroexe donde comprar viagra lexapro stored in fat por cuanto tiempo debo usar differin for wrinkles tizanidine arrow 4 mg opinie omeprazole helicid 20 mg buspirone 5 mg engorda docusate sodium liquid dose of benadryl mixing liquid finasteride and minoxidil nizoral percent hairfall shampoo canada panchatatva ayurvedic face pack ingredients in aleve hapenxin cephalexin 250 mg amoxicillin 500 mg 3 times a day sinus infection over counter medicine similar protonix drug sang ju yin ingredients in benadryl dicyclomine hydrochloride dextropropoxyphene buy cheap avodart no prescription tac dung thuoc roxithromycin 150 mg to g dimetapp inactive ingredients in benadryl can i buy cialis in pharmacy jakarta santé canada viagra generic prednisone 10mg and alcohol buy tadalafil malaysia compare prices viagra cvs walgreens how can i get real viagra cheap viagra austin is 150 mg of wellbutrin a lot para que sirve la pomada arbest piroxicam benzoyl peroxide 2 5 bestellen in english epiduo adapalene and benzoyl peroxide reviews of london lithium battery explosion temperature in orlando chloramphenicol ointment buy pantozol 40 mg wirkung viagra prednisone for herniated disc in back singulair sobres 5 mg candesartan side effects uk national lottery divalproex 250 mg espanol normal aspirin mg nutsedge killer ingredients in aleve electrasol tabs ingredients in aleve singulair 5 mg dose wockhardt promethazine with codeine price losartan 100 mg bioequivalence study protocol nexium 40 mg dosering birra e viagra generic can buy viagra tokyo furosemide 40 mg bodybuilding exercises cipla amoxicillin tablets prices in rupees acyclovir 200 mg no pres ranba brand lasix ampicillin concentration in lb plates borders what is nortriptyline 50 mg used for clomid meaning in hindi lithium ion battery safety issues and solutions doxazosin user reviews orlistat 120mg capsules reviews aciclovir tabletas 400 mg en espanol dogs liquid ivermectin heart worms side effects of progesterone suppositories 200 mg 100 mg cialis remeron 7.5 or 15 mg paroxetine hydrochloride tablets 20 mg aripiprazole health canada brand name cefixime azithromycin combination lock calcitriol package insert pdf in excel wellbutrin sr 150 mg half life definition 100 mg bupropion with 50mg tramadol dilantin in status epilepticus propecia customer reviews levitra kosten in pattaya es peligroso usar misoprostol losartan 50 brands orlistat medicine information in urdu best antidepressant to combine with wellbutrin mac lip erase ingredients in aleve andis profoil lithium shaver reviews generic celebrex release pettinice ingredients in aleve amoxicillin where to get in europa digoxin metabolism in rats can i cut a 150mg diflucan in half haloperidol liquidos ciprofloxacin in community acquired pneumonia case zovirax 400 mg dosierungstabelle cialis in mexico prices reglan available over counter cataflam 25 mg untuk ibu best deal generic levitra 20mg nisargalaya brahmi hair oil user reviews liquid amoxicillin 250mg efectos secundarios nolvadex 20 mg volmax watches ukay buy feldene now viagra and its substitutes in the uk adalat meaning in tamil safe to give dog claritin glipizide 5 mg twice a day training buy teva generic escitalopram ic verapamil sa 240 mg exelon glassdoor salary reviews pyridium safe pregnancy benadryl safe 16 month old cetirizine 10mg uk naproxen over the counter equivalent uk diovan bula anvisa silimed tretinoin gel acne reviews xenical 120mg made in turkey drugstores in the philippines that have tamoxifen ingredients elocon ointment usage metronidazole 250 mg tablet for dogs aldactone generico de crestor claritin d ingredients mg accutane low dose review when does risperdal consta go generic viagra names in pakistan valsartan 80 mg diovan nielit 50 mg zoloft best benzoyl peroxide brands in the philippines over the counter protonix generic names misoprostol price canada gonorrhea levofloxacin 500 mg 5 days formestane vs letrozole in men canada drugs asacol were to by viagra in brazil olanzapine tab 15 mg aspirin analgin in pregnancy cedax generico do viagra where can i buy cytotec in bahrain finpecia tablet reviews motilium over the counter australia weather side effects with anxiety in pm on celexa small volume provera operation market does walmart pharmacy sell cialis what will 600 mg of ibuprofen do what is indian viagra tell in urdu briefly norethindrone 0 35 mg tablet reviews

The Iran Brief®

Policy, Trade & Strategic Affairs

An investigative tool for business executives, government, and the media.

Rogue States and Ballistic Missiles:

Lessons and Prospects

Paper presented before the

Commission To Assess the Ballistic Missile Threat to the United States

(the "Rumsfeld Commission"), April 1998

by Kenneth R. Timmerman

Director, the Middle East Data Project, Inc.; Publisher, The Iran Brief.
Copyright © 1998, Middle East Data Project, Inc.

One can draw a number of lessons from the public record on how well we in the United States do the job of preventing ballistic missile programs (and by inference, other WMD programs and technologies) in developing nations, especially in what are now called the "rogue states."

I confess a modicum of responsibility for coining this term while working on the professional staff of the House Foreign Relations Committee in 1993, when we did a series of hearings on Iran (1), Iraq (2), and North Korea. Some have objected that the term "rogue regime" is too lapidary, in that each of the five countries normally referred to (Iran, Iraq, North Korea, Libya, Cuba) present dramatically different realities. However, I still believe that from a proliferation standpoint, the term is useful because many of the problems non-proliferators face with these regimes are remarkably similar.

The point of view I will present today, however, is that of a non-government specialist who has had the good fortune of being the first Western journalist to have discoursed at length with the heads of Iraq's ballistic missile and nuclear weapons programs in Baghdad, starting in 19863. I have also spent a great deal of time poking through weapons factories in a variety of developing nations. And finally, as a journalist I have spoken at length - and repeatedly - both to Iranian missile designers and to many of their Western suppliers, and have followed the arms and technology markets in that part of the world for more than fifteen years4.

So what you will hear from me today is a "ground zero" perspective, not a policy pronouncement or an analyst's forensic reconstruction.

I believe we have done the job poorly because we do not get out in the field often enough. And when we do get out in the field, we go to the wrong places or listen to the wrong people. Or, even worse, if we do hear the truth, we are culturally bound to reject it, because it challenges our basic preconceptions about the ability of Third World countries to do things we have always considered to be our unique province.

Lesson 1: The U.S. can't seem to keep an eye on more than one ball at a time.

Iraq: In the mid-1980s, the U.S. focused intently on Iraqi procurement activities aimed at developing a 2000 kilometer-range nuclear-capable missile, known in the West as Condor-2, which the Iraqis referred to as Badr-2000 or Project 395.

Condor-2 was initially intended to grow out of an existing shorter-range missile developed by Argentina with German assistance, the Condor-1. The U.S. government became alarmed when it began to detect major transfers of technology, first to Argentina, by Germany's premier aerospace concern, MBB. As investigators looked further, they discovered that MBB was only the tip of the iceberg, and that major firms across Europe were all contributing to what became known as an joint Iraqi-Argentinean-Egyptian program. Snia Bpd in Italy provided solid-fuel propellant technology; Sagem in France sold guidance kits; Egypt's Abu Zaabal Specialty Chemical Company helped to build the Taj al-Ma'arik solid fuel propellant plant in Latifiyah (al Hillah), while former MBB and Krupp group engineers working out of Switzerland in the Consen group provided overall program management. Even U.S. companies such as Electronic Associates Inc., Gould, Hewlett Packard, Tektronix, Scientific Atlanta, and Wiltron, legally sold equipment to the Saad 16 (known as the Al Kindi Research complex as of 1989), until the U.S. began denying licenses to Iraqi-based facilities known to be involved in Condor-2 in 1986.

The U.S. was so obsessed with stopping Condor-2 that the Pentagon, with the blessing of the White House, launched an extraordinary - and initially successful - diplomatic effort, to create an international club of missile suppliers specifically aimed at stopping Condor-2. Today that organization, the MTCR, has become an exporters cartel, not a control mechanism. But when it was first established in 1985, two years before the MTCR was actually ratified in public, it immediately set to work to frustrate Iraq's procurement of solid-fuel propellants and precision guidance kits for the Condor-2.

By all accounts, the MTCR succeeded its initial mission. While Iraq did manage to set up a solid-fuel propellant plant and to purchase large mixers from Germany for manufacturing the Condor-2 boosters, the vigorous international effort led by the United States prevented key technologies - especially guidance - from reaching Baghdad. The end result was the Condor-2 never took off.

But here's the rub: while all eyes were on Iraq's solid-fuel program, the Iraqis were quietly moving in another direction. In 1986, at least two years after the Iraqis realized that the Condor-2 was being targeted by the Americans (because of the prosecution in the U.S. of an Egyptian military attaché involved in procuring carbon fiber and other material for the missile nose cone), the Iraqis launched a crash program to extend the range of their Soviet-built SCUD-B missiles. In the immediately term, they wanted the range to hit the Iranian capital, Teheran. Further down the line, they wanted to reach Israel.

Western analysts have tended to pooh-pooh the extended SCUD program in Iraq, but they miss the point: this is the one that worked. The Iraqis succeeded in re-engineering the SCUD-B in something like 18 months - and that's from the start of the program to operational missile launch. It was these extended-range SCUD-Bs, now known as the al-Hussein, that Iraq rained down on Tehran during the February 1988 War of the Cities. Their use is credited (along with Iraq's extensive use of CW during the campaign to liberate Fao) with convincing Ayatollah Khomeini to throw in the towel later that year.

Iran: In Iran, a similar obsession with what was "known" appears to have blind-sided U.S. government policy-makers (and I am being kind here) to what was actually going on in the decision-making centers and the research labs of Iranian missile programs.

Iran did not have the same problems with range that beleaguered the Iraqis. Baghdad has always been within range of Iranian SCUD-Bs, without modification. So all during the 1980s, it was assumed that Iran had no strategic interest in developing longer-range missiles.

After the Iran-Iraq war, the U.S. became concerned with Iranian-North Korean missile cooperation. Early reports, leaked to press, suggested that Iran had purchased SCUD-C missiles with a range of 600+ kilometers. That brought Saudi Arabia, parts of Turkey, and even Pakistan in reach - but, most people felt, so what?

Then in April 1993, reports started to surface in the New York Times and Jane's Intelligence Review, about a deal concluded between Iran and North Korea one month earlier to co-develop the Nodong-2, a new missile with a range in excess of 1,200 kilometers and perhaps as greater as 1,500 kilometers. This would bring Israel into range of Iran for the first time, and received a lot of attention - not only from the press, but from the White House.

I remember approximately one year later by Martin Indyk, who was then the top NSC official dealing with the Middle East, that the U.S. had succeeded in blocking the Nodong-2 program in Iran. This was subsequently billed as an unintended positive consequence of the U.S.-North Korean negotiations over the North Korean nuclear weapons program.

For more than three years, the word in Washington was that Iran's longer-range missile programs had been blocked, because we had succeeded in cutting off their primary source of technology: North Korea.

But guess what: while all eyes were focused on Pyongyang, the Iranians were going elsewhere. It was precisely at this point, when North Korean assistance appears to have stopped or at least slowed, in mid-1994, that the Iranians turned in serious fashion toward Russia for the missile needs. This led eventually to two separate families of intermediate and intercontinental ballistic missiles, the first of which, the Shahab-3, appears to be ready for production later this year. I have chronicled the abysmal failure of the United States government to wake up to reinvigorated Iranian missile programs in the Reader's Digest (Jan. 1998) and my own newsletter, The Iran Brief.

I am convinced - and we can discuss this later on - that the Clinton administration chose at a political level to push aside intelligence information about the Russian assistance to Iran for long enough to be unable to prevent the most critical transfers. As a result, Iran will test-fire its Shahab-3 later this year, and this missile will be deployed where it can threaten U.S. troops in Saudi Arabia and Turkey, as well as Israel, within two years.

Lesson 2: The bad guys are much more skilled than we tend to give them credit for.

Journalists have a term they use to designate nationals of Third World countries where taxis are cheap, security officials monitor your day-to-day contacts, and the trains don't run on time: they call them "rag-heads."

But journalists are not alone in under-estimating the technical skills, the scientific achievements, or the cultural depth of the nations that today threaten U.S. interests in the Middle East the most, Iran and Iraq.

I can remember vividly long conversations in Baghdad hotels with French and German aerospace engineers, who lamented the inability of the Iraqis to use the fabulous technology they were putting at their disposal. One Frenchman from Aérospatiale claimed the Iraqis regularly tried to blame their lack of success with the Exocet missiles on factory defects, when in fact the Iraqis were storing them in open sheds out in the desert. German and Americans I interviewed who were selling machine-tools to the Iraqis never believed they would be able to use them to manufacture anything more sophisticated than a dumb steel-bomb. Surprise. The UN Special Commission for the Disarmament of Iraq, UNSCOM, found these same machine-tools in facilities designed to manufacture HEU bomb cores and tungsten-carbide penetrators.

Iraq continues to have at least 10,000 skilled nuclear scientists and technicians, and tens of thousands more Western-trained engineers who continue to work on new weapons development.

We think they won't succeed in designing a new intermediate--range ballistic missile capable without testing? How do you think the Iraqis have succeeded in pumping any oil over the past five years? It hasn't been through massive infusions of Western technology or spare parts. They have the manpower, and the skills, the make-do with what they have got. The paradigm is not that of Saudi Arabia or the UAE - or even the oil-spoiled Iraq of the 1970s. The comparison should be that of Winston Churchill's Britain under Nazi siege.

While Iran does not feel the same pinch as Iraq as a general rule, the Revolutionary Guards thrive on a similar siege mentality. They have trained tens of thousands of weapons designers over the past 15 years, and have demonstrated a high level of skills both in resolving technical problems, and in beating Western embargoes.

Lesson 3: Our export control system is not merely broken; it is nonexistent.

In the 1980s and early 1990s, we had tools and a relatively solid international consensus in preventing the leakage of Western technology to the Soviet Union through the mechanism of COCOM. Following Iraq's invasion of Kuwait, the Bush administration attempted understandably to adapt COCOM to deal with the emerging proliferation threat. While to many in Europe, this smacked of a U.S. damage-control effort, they nevertheless went along in the beginning because they also recognized the dangers of countries such as Iran or Iraq equipped with WMD.

The dramatic shift in emphasis that began in September 1993 under the Clinton administration to dismantle COCOM, while favoring U.S. computer exports to China, was seen by our allies as the first ever U.S. action that actually corroborated paranoid fantasies that had surfaced periodically over the years that the United States saw COCOM as a means of obtaining commercial advantage over European or Japanese suppliers.

This proved fatal to COCOM; and the organization was dismantled unilaterally by the Clinton administration on April 1, 1994.

Since then, our former COCOM allies have maintained national controls on high-tech exports to the rogue states - and in the case of Germany, they have been very effective. But the U.S. has shown that the lure of exports will get the better of national controls whenever large commercial contracts are at stake (viz., China). The result has been largely a self-fulfilling prophesy. Those who called export controls a "wasting asset" in 1992 - William Perry, Ashton Carton, and Mitchel Wallerstein, the three co-authors of a seminar study by the National Academy of Sciences - were all appointed to senior positions by President Clinton and used their new powers to abolish those controls, regardless of their effectiveness.

We can bemoan the results all we wish. But the result is that our nonproliferation toolbox today is virtually empty.

In a funny way, the Clinton administration has recognized this. When it became imperative to further restrict Iran's access to American technology - because critical dual-use items were slipping through - the administration decided in May 1995 to decree a total trade embargo, knowing they couldn't enforce a selective tightening of export restrictions.

The ultimate downside to this situation is the erosion of any international consensus for control regimes. The administration has contributed to this by inviting known proliferators - Russia and Brazil come first to mind - into regimes such as the MTCR.

To fill this policy void, the Pentagon invented "counter-proliferation."


My predictions are bleak, based on what we know from the UNSCOM inspections in Iraq, and what I know from my own reporting on Iran.

• Iraq has maintained a broad-based missile production capability, within the 150-km range-limit imposed by UN Security Council Resolutions. It is clear that Iraq has designed new missiles with a much longer range. Without second-guessing our intelligence experts about existing missiles and launchers the Iraqis have hidden from UNSCOM, it is also clear that Iraq will be able to jump-start a new production program within months, if not weeks, of the end of UN sanctions.

• Iran will succeed in deploying the Shahab-3 within he next 18 months. This will bring Israel into range for the first time, as well as U.S. staging areas in Turkey and Saudi Arabia. Further down the line, Iran may succeed in developing the Shahab-4, with an estimated range of 2000 kilometers, and is known to be working on a second family of solid-fuel ICBMs capable of reaching Western Europe and the east coast of the United States. While those missiles are further out, the speed with which the Iranians developed Shahab-3 (approximately 5 years from the initial Nodong agreement with North Korea to the anticipated test-launch of a production missile later this year) should give us pause when we try to estimate a target deployment date for these missiles.

Given our demonstrated inability of preventing proliferation in these two rogue states, I believe we are in a race with time to see whether our adversaries will succeed first in developing these new missiles, or whether we will be capable of fielding limited theater missile defenses to deter them.


1 "U.S. Security Policy Toward Rogue Regimes," Subcommittee on International Security, International Organizations and Human Rights, House Committee on Foreign Affairs, July 28 and Sept 14, 1993; ISBN 01-16-043984-1, printed in 1994; with attachments on U.S. dual use exports to Iran.s

2 "Iraq's Nuclear Weapons Capability and IAEA Inspections in Iraq," Joint hearing before the Subcommittees on Europe and the Middle East and International Security, International Organizations and Human Rights of the House Committee on Foreign Affairs, June 29, 1993, ISBN 0-16-041691-4. Includes a Staff report written by Kenneth R. Timmerman, "Iraq Rebuilts Its Military Industries."

3 I chronicled the Iraqi weapons program in The Death Lobby: How the West Armed Iraq, Houghton Mifflin, 1991 (also available as a Bantam paperback in the UK and in various foreign language editions).

4 See in particular, Kenneth R. Timmerman, "Missile Threat from Iran," Reader's Digest, January 1998; and various issues of our newsletter, Iran Brief.

The Middle East Data Project, Inc., is a private corporation engaged in the analysis of strategic trade to countries of proliferation concern that contracts to private and government clients and publishes a monthly investigative newsletter, The Iran Brief.